US. Texas’s threat to boot BlackRock from pension funds forces corporations into can’t-win battle over ESG investing

Hi from Geneva, Switzerland. Peter Vanham here, filling in for Alan.

I’m Fortune’s newly minted executive editor, responsible for the Connect learning platform. I’ll also be joining Alan in writing on corporate America’s turn to stakeholder capitalism and sustainable business practices.

Speaking of which, in the latest backlash to ESG, Texas state comptroller Glenn Hegar yesterday listed BlackRock and nine other asset managers using ESG investing as “financial companies that boycott energy companies.” He warned BlackRock and Co. would be “subject to divestment” by the state’s multibillion-dollar pension funds.

That does not seem like a pleasant prospect, and it sure looks like Hegar means it. “The ESG movement has produced an opaque and perverse system in which some financial companies no longer make decisions in the best interest of their shareholders or their clients, but…to push a social and political agenda shrouded in secrecy,” he said.

The comptroller’s words sound eerily similar to what Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and his State Board of Administration decided earlier this week. They too will ban “social, political, or ideological interests” when making investment decisions for the state’s pension fund.

Initiatives like these will force the companies in question—and many others, no doubt—to reassess their embrace of environmental, social, and corporate governance investment practices.

That is almost certain to end in a “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” scenario. It’s hard to please both sides in a thorny political debate. Just ask Disney, which tried to do just that following Florida’s “Don’t Say Gay” initiative, only to anger all parties involved.

Read more @Fortune

274 views